Visit These 7 Bella Italian Restaurants in Santa Monica
Santa Monica's Italian restaurant scene offers far more than tourist-trap spaghetti joints along the pier. Tucked between Montana Avenue's boutiques and the Pacific Ocean's edge, seven exceptional trattorias and osterias deliver everything from celebrity-favorite coastal classics to cheese wheel theatrics that'll make your Instagram followers drool. Whether craving handmade pasta from a Michelin-starred chef or wood-fired pizza steps from the beach, these spots prove that California's coastal city rivals any Italian neighborhood—without the transatlantic flight.
This post contains affiliate links. Miimu may receive compensation from purchases you make, at no extra cost to you.
Felix Trattoria: Handmade Pasta Perfection
Chef Evan Funke transformed a former Joe's Restaurant space on Abbot Kinney Boulevard into Venice's hottest Italian reservation. The glass-enclosed pasta lab lets diners watch skilled hands roll sfincione and shape tagliatelle while they sip Barbarossa cocktails at the bar. Funke's rigorous commitment to traditional techniques means every strand of pasta gets crafted daily using old-world methods he learned from Italian grandmothers.
The menu organizes pasta by Italian region—rigatoni all'amatriciana represents Central Italy with massive guanciale chunks, while lemony Sicilian spaghetti brings southern coastal flavors. The sfincione focaccia arrives doused in olive oil and earns universal praise as a must-order starter. Reservations open 7 days ahead at 10am and disappear within minutes, so set an alarm or prepare for a 2-hour wait hoping to snag one of 9 walk-in bar stools.
What makes Felix Trattoria's pasta special? Every pasta shape gets handmade daily using traditional Italian techniques in the visible pasta lab, with recipes organized by Italy's four culinary regions for authentic regional flavor profiles.
How far in advance should reservations be made at Felix Trattoria? Reservations become available exactly 7 days beforehand at 10am and typically book completely within minutes due to the restaurant's 24-seat capacity and overwhelming popularity.
Does Felix Trattoria accept walk-ins? The restaurant reserves 9 bar stools and 2 tables for walk-ins, but expect waits of 2+ hours before the 5pm opening, especially on weekends.
Giorgio Baldi: Celebrity Scene With Serious Seafood
This Pacific Palisades institution has served coastal Italian cuisine for 30 years while attracting Hollywood's A-list crowd. Rihanna reportedly dines here 6 times per week when she's in town, drawn by the family-run warmth and signature agnolotti stuffed with sweet corn in white truffle sauce. The $25 tiny ravioli portions might shock budget-conscious diners, but regulars insist the silky pasta justifies every dollar.
The menu stays traditional with shaved fennel salad, massive burrata portions, and lots of $90 lobster orders that double as status symbols. Fresh Dover sole and langoustine pasta showcase the restaurant's seafood strengths, with imported white truffles from Piedmont arriving each fall. The cramped, modest dining room feels more neighborhood trattoria than glitzy hotspot until 8pm when Pacific Palisades residents descend from nearby estates transforming the space into LA's unofficial celebrity dining room.
What is Giorgio Baldi's most famous dish? The agnolotti stuffed with sweet corn and white truffle sauce ranks as the signature dish and best item on the menu at $25 for approximately 10 tiny ravioli.
Why do celebrities frequent Giorgio Baldi? The family-owned restaurant's 30-year history, authentic Italian approach, intimate atmosphere, and consistently excellent seafood attract high-profile clientele including Rihanna who visits multiple times weekly.
How expensive is dining at Giorgio Baldi? Expect to spend approximately $300 per person for a full meal with appetizers, entrees, and drinks at this upscale Pacific Palisades establishment.
Forma: Pasta Finished in Giant Cheese Wheels
Montana Avenue's buzziest Italian spot serves pasta "Dalla Forma"—tossed inside hollowed-out wheels of cheese before plating. Executive Chef Piero Topputo and General Manager Mario Sabatini created this theatrical preparation method where servers carry Chitarra Cacio e Pepe to the back corner's cheese station, then return with steaming, fragrant, irresistibly cheesy results. Diners can glimpse the process but true cheese wheel fans should request back corner seating for optimal viewing.
The cheese bar displays 70+ international selections organized by texture from semi-firm to stinky blue-veined varieties. Carbonara, mushroom truffle tortellini, and risotto with veal sauce all receive the cheese wheel treatment while char-grilled Spanish octopus and filet mignon tartare satisfy non-pasta cravings. Happy hour runs 3-6pm daily with specials on wines and small plates making this Montana Avenue destination surprisingly accessible despite its sophisticated modern decor.
What does "Dalla Forma" mean at Forma Restaurant? Dalla Forma describes the unique preparation method where freshly cooked pasta gets finished by tossing inside large wheels of cheese before serving, creating intensely cheesy, aromatic results.
Can diners watch the cheese wheel pasta preparation? The cheese wheel preparation happens in the dining room's back corner, visible from certain tables, though it's not performed tableside, so request back seating for the best view.
Does Forma Restaurant offer non-pasta options? The menu includes char-grilled Spanish octopus, filet mignon tartare, braised short ribs, and Faroe Island salmon alongside the cheese-focused pasta dishes.
Élephante: Rooftop Mediterranean With Ocean Views
Nick Mathers' Wish You Were Here Group transformed a rooftop into southern Italy's Aeolian Islands. The second-floor beach house channels Pantelleria with cactus gardens, natural wood, stone surfaces, and unbeatable sunset room ocean views. Contemporary small plates deliver surprising Mediterranean flavors—rich whipped eggplant spread with puccia bread, rigatoni verde with mushroom ragù, and burrata pizza showcasing imported Italian ingredients.
The seasonal menu emphasizes sharing plates that work equally well for tranquil afternoon drinks or decadent dinner transitioning into lively late-night cocktails. Michelin Guide recognition confirms what locals already know—this isn't just another pretty rooftop but serious coastal Italian cooking elevated by thoughtful ingredient sourcing. Weekend brunch expands hours while Friday and Saturday extend service until 1am for Santa Monica's most sophisticated late-night dining.
What type of cuisine does Élephante serve? Coastal Italian with Southern Mediterranean influences inspired by Sicily's Pantelleria and the Aeolian Islands, emphasizing contemporary small plates and seasonal ingredients.
Does Élephante have ocean views? The rooftop location at 1332 2nd Street offers spectacular Pacific Ocean views, especially from the sunset room with natural wood and stone design.
What are Élephante's hours? Monday-Thursday 10am-midnight, Friday-Saturday 9am-1am, Sunday 9am-midnight, with extended late-night service making it Santa Monica's rare sophisticated late dining option.
Explore more delicious restaurants at the Southern California beaches.
Milo and Olive: All-Day Bakery Meets Pizzeria
Josh Loeb and Zoe Nathan's Wilshire Boulevard gem operates 7am-10pm daily as neighborhood bakery, breakfast spot, and pizzeria. Nathan's pastry expertise shines through rustic morning treats while wood-fired pizzas and handmade pastas anchor lunch and dinner. The famous garlic knot—pizza dough filled with sauteed garlic cloves, olive oil, and thyme—arrives crisp outside, plush within, earning universal acclaim as a carbohydrate bomb worth every calorie.
Pork belly sausage pizza with braised greens and mixed mushroom pie with fontina demonstrate the kitchen's seasonal farmers market approach. Communal tables encourage neighborhood mingling while counter seating lets guests watch chefs work the wood-burning Mugnaini oven. Early closers might score day-old pastries and bread loaves as parting gifts—yesterday's ham and cheese croissant makes exceptional next-day breakfast according to regular customers.
What makes Milo and Olive unique? The restaurant functions as all-day neighborhood bakery and pizzeria, open 7am-10pm with pastry chef Zoe Nathan's exceptional baked goods complementing wood-fired pizzas and handmade pastas.
Does Milo and Olive accommodate dietary restrictions? The menu includes gluten-free, vegan, and vegetarian options throughout breakfast, lunch, and dinner service.
What is Milo and Olive's signature dish? The wood-fired garlic knot—pizza dough filled with sauteed garlic cloves, olive oil, and thyme—receives universal praise as the must-order item.
Piccolo Ristoranti: Michelin Pedigree Returns
Chef Antonio Murè reopened his original Piccolo concept with locations on Lincoln Boulevard and Abbot Kinney Boulevard. Murè earned Michelin stars at La Botte before closing that restaurant, bringing his extensive recipe collection and Sicilian roots to these neighborhood establishments. Partner Tony Black handles management while Chef de Cuisine Victorino Balbino—Murè's collaborator since 2004—maintains consistency across both locations.
Homemade pasta courses include squid ink spaghetti with shrimp and scallops, pumpkin ravioli, and green tagliatelle with lamb ragù. Fresh fish preparations like Mediterranean sea bass and wild game options showcase Murè's range beyond pasta. The carefully curated wine list and handcrafted cocktails complement an ever-evolving menu that blends farmers market freshness with imported Italian ingredients. Santa Monica's location operates nightly for dinner while plans expand into lunch and brunch service.
What is Chef Antonio Murè's background? Murè earned Michelin stars at La Botte in downtown Santa Monica and has opened 11 restaurants throughout his career, drawing on Sicilian roots and time working in Italy's Dolomites.
How many Piccolo locations exist? Two locations operate in the Santa Monica-Venice area: 2127 Lincoln Boulevard in Santa Monica (open nightly) and 1616 Abbot Kinney Boulevard in Venice (Tuesday-Saturday).
What are Piccolo's signature dishes? Squid ink pasta with shrimp and scallops, pumpkin ravioli, green tagliatelle with lamb ragù, and grilled Mediterranean sea bass receive frequent praise.
Colapasta: Michelin Guide Recognition Without the Price Tag
Chef Stefano De Lorenzo brought his Michelin-starred La Botte pedigree to this modern trattoria blocks from the Pacific. Colapasta earned Michelin Guide inclusion, Eater LA's "16 Hottest Restaurants" designation, and LA Times' "15 Best Dishes of 2019" through farm-to-table pasta prepared at surprisingly affordable prices. De Lorenzo sources organic ingredients from Santa Monica Farmers' Market, creating seasonal menus that shift with California's harvest cycles.
Regional Italian pasta dishes represent different areas—Roman carbonara, Sicilian seafood preparations, Northern Italian ragùs—all executed with technical precision in a casual beach setting. The approach merges five-star technique with neighborhood accessibility, letting diners experience Michelin-quality cooking without formal dress codes or $200 per person tabs. The breezy location and emphasis on local sourcing create authentic Italian flavors filtered through California's agricultural abundance.
Why did Colapasta receive Michelin Guide recognition? Chef Stefano De Lorenzo's Michelin-starred background, technical pasta expertise, commitment to organic Santa Monica Farmers' Market sourcing, and affordable pricing earned Michelin Guide inclusion.
How much does dinner cost at Colapasta? The restaurant emphasizes gourmet food at affordable prices, making Michelin-quality pasta accessible without the typical fine dining expense.
What makes Colapasta's pasta special? House-made pasta combines regional Italian recipes with fresh organic ingredients sourced same-day from Santa Monica Farmers' Market, creating seasonal menus that change with California's harvest.
Plan Your Santa Monica Italian Food Tour With Miimu
Ready to eat your way through Santa Monica's best Italian restaurants? Don't let this guide disappear when you close your browser. Sign up for Miimu to save and organize these seven restaurants into a living dining bundle you can update anytime. Add new discoveries, group spots by neighborhood or cuisine style, track which ones you've visited, and keep everything ready for your next pasta craving.